Presented for your amusement: During my past couple of years in graduate school, studying integrated marketing communications, I've been subjected to reading sometimes insufferable meanderings from some of my fellow students on a discussion board. Their sins and follies will be clear.

Sixteen Rules for Discussion Questions

1. Spell properly.
2. Use good grammar. The style of a post can be less formal than an academic paper, but that is not carte blanche for language abuse.
3. The word "media" is plural. It is not "mediums" or "medias."
4. How you feel is irrelevant. How you think may not be. Likewise, what you believe seldom counts. What you know and can prove matters.
5. Don't use clichés.
6. Don't use big words when small ones will do. Smart people can spot posers.
7. Superfluous "quotes" are "irritating."
8. Don't dance. Be succinct. Indulge in no tangents! Stick to the point. Always refer to the original question.
9. Adding "Thoughts?" at the end of a post does not stimulate conversation in a meaningful way.
10. "Good post!" or simply agreeing with a post doesn't advance the discussion. Don't apple polish. Being respectfully critical enhances the conversation.
11. Make posts relevant to the original question. Focusing upon an example case without relevance to the question is worse than no post at all, because everyone is forced to read something that doesn't have any significance to the question.
12. References to the lesson, assigned readings and relevant outside sources are helpful.
13. When quoting outside sources, use only relevant portions. Ellipses (…) are a reader's friend.
14. Long quotes from outside sources without your thoughtful commentaries do not prove you know the subject.
15. Don't use Wikipedia as a source.
16. Don't quote yourself.

© 2008 Butch Maxwell


Complete Waste of Web Space | Maxims | Links
Email Me